Tesla Model Y: Which Tire Provides the Best Comfort?

Criticized for its poor cushioning comfort, the Tesla Model Y can be improved with the right tire choice.

The cushioning comfort of tires is a key criterion for a Tesla Model Y, especially due to its relatively firm suspension and heavy weight from the batteries. Here is a ranking of the best alternatives to the very disappointing – but cheap at factory output – tires Hankook that come standard, in order to find cushioning comfort, but also acoustic comfort.

To prevent any trouble or doubt, Tesla recommends tires identified by a specific T0 marking on the sidewall, indicating their compliance with the specifications of the American manufacturer. This is the case for the tires offered below.

Finally, never lose sight of the fact that electric cars, especially large and heavy SUVs, consume their tires much more than their thermal counterparts. Their immediate torque when accelerating, but especially their weight, impose strong constraints on the rubber. And since magic doesn’t exist…

1. Michelin e.Primacy

🏆 Best choice for overall comfort

The Michelin e.Primacy is designed to offer excellent shock absorption and smoothness on uneven roads. It is often recommended for electric vehicles due to its low rolling resistance and good level of silence.

Why is it interesting for the Tesla Model Y?

✔️ Absorption of irregularities: Its soft rubber compound and design with an optimized tread pattern allow for better vibration absorption.
✔️ Quiet rolling: It produces very little noise thanks to specially designed tread patterns that reduce resonance.
✔️ Low rolling resistance: This improves range, a crucial point for an EV like the Model Y.
✔️ Good balance between comfort and longevity: It is robust and offers good durability without sacrificing comfort.

Disadvantages

❌ Less performance in dynamic driving compared to sportier tires.
❌ Adequate grip in the rain, but there are better options on wet surfaces.

➡️ Recommended in 255/45 R19 for maximum comfort on the Tesla Model Y.

2. Pirelli P-Zero Elect

🔇 Ideal for reducing road noise

The Pirelli P-Zero Elect is specifically designed for electric SUVs like the Tesla Model Y. It features PNCS technology (Pirelli Noise Cancelling System) which reduces resonance noise in the cabin.

Why is it interesting for the Tesla Model Y?

✔️ Soft sidewalls: Allow for better absorption of road imperfections.
✔️ Enhanced silence: With the internal PNCS foam, it reduces tire-generated noise by up to 25%.
✔️ Good rolling resistance: Contributes to better range.
✔️ Good grip in the rain: Better water evacuation than the Michelin e.Primacy.

Disadvantages

❌ Higher price than other alternatives.
❌ May be slightly firmer than the Michelin e.Primacy, although this is offset by noise reduction.

➡️ An excellent choice for those who want to maximize silence inside their Tesla Model Y, in 255/45 R19 or 255/40 R20.

3. Continental UltraContact NXT

🔋 Optimized for range and riding comfort

The Continental UltraContact NXT is a tire focused on energy efficiency and comfort. It is often chosen for electric vehicles due to its low rolling resistance.

Why is it interesting for the Tesla Model Y?

✔️ Very good riding comfort: Its flexible rubber absorbs road imperfections well.
✔️ Excellent range: Its low rolling resistance helps conserve energy.
✔️ Good longevity: It offers more uniform wear than other tires in its category.

Disadvantages

❌ Less performance on wet surfaces compared to some competitors.
❌ Less grip in sporty driving.

➡️ Recommended for those who want to maximize range without sacrificing comfort, in 255/45 R19.

4. Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6

🏎 Best compromise between comfort and dynamism

The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 is a performance tire that remains comfortable, offering good cushioning of imperfections while maintaining good road holding.

Why is it interesting for the Tesla Model Y?

✔️ Good filtering of imperfections: A good balance between rigidity and flexibility allows for a pleasant drive even on degraded roads.
✔️ Excellent road holding: Better grip than other tires on this list, while remaining relatively comfortable.
✔️ Good performance in the rain: Excellent water evacuation.

Disadvantages

❌ Noisier than the Michelin e.Primacy or Pirelli P-Zero Elect.
❌ Less optimized for range than a Continental EcoContact 6.

➡️ A good choice if you’re looking for a solid compromise between performance and comfort, in 255/40 R20.

Comparison of Tires for the Tesla Model Y

Final advice: which tire to choose?

• For the best overall comfort → Michelin e.Primacy (ideal for degraded roads).
• For maximum silence → Pirelli P-Zero Elect (thanks to PNCS technology).
• To maximize range → Continental UltraContact NXT.
• For a compromise between comfort and performance → Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6.

👉 If you want to maximize comfort, prefer the 19-inch size (255/45 R19). The 20 or 21-inch versions will offer more sportiness but will be firmer.

ALSO READ: Highway charging: a tariff scandal that the state is complicit in